Four Seattle residents have filed claims alleging that the city has, for years, been collecting millions of dollars in extra" garbage fees from residents despite knowing the fees are inaccurate.
The tort claims, filed this week, are the first step in a proposed class action lawsuit against the city.
The legal action follows a Seattle Times report on the city's practice of charging fees for "extra garbage," propped against a bin or overflowing out of the top.
The city charges $13.95 for each instance of "extra garbage" documented by its contracted garbage collectors. Seattle Public Utilities charged for extra garbage more than 342,000 times last year, sometimes for multiple bags, bringing in about $8.7 million.
The new claims allege that Seattle has known that its garbage collectors are inaccurately reporting the fees. It also alleges that Seattle's contracts with solid waste collectors Recology and Waste Management indirectly incentivize the companies to report "extra garbage" fees.
"Despite alarming reporting inconsistencies, the City has continued to collect these charges," an addendum to the filed claims says. "The City expects customers to expend their own time and resources correcting its staggeringly flawed system — one bill at a time."
The claimants are seeking a class action to reimburse SPU customers for "unfair and unlawful charges" and to ensure that the city accurately reports charges in the future.
Both Seattle Public Utilities and the city's office of finance, which receives tort claims, declined to comment Wednesday.
The four residents filing claims, represented by Stritmatter Law, are Elizabeth Forsyth, Patti Gorman, Karen Deyerle and Hugh Rubin.
Forsyth was featured in a Seattle Times story last spring, reporting that she'd found years’ worth of what she thought were bogus "extra garbage" fees on her utility bill.
“I am happy to pay for garbage that I set out, or if someone is illegally dumping on my property, that’s my responsibility, too,” Forsyth said in April. “If you’ve got a photo of it, I am happy to pay for it, but I believe these are fraud.”
Seattle's contracts with garbage collectors tell the collectors to document when extra garbage is left out on the curb and say that the city will periodically monitor random addresses to assess the collectors' accuracy. The contractors are then paid a bonus for each percentage point above 95% accuracy and docked for each point below 85% accuracy.
But, the claims allege, the way the city monitors accuracy ensures that collectors are incentivized to overreport extra garbage.
City inspectors periodically photograph each instance of extra garbage that they see on their rounds, and then that is matched against what garbage inspectors report. But garbage collectors are docked only if they don't report extra garbage that the city found. They are not docked, the claims allege, if they report extra garbage where the city found none.
"The City only audited to make sure that the contractors were reporting extra waste," the claims say. "It did not audit to make sure the contractors accurately reported the absence of extra waste."
In other words, the claim alleges the city is working to ensure it gets paid for extra garbage, but not making the same effort to avoid wrongful charges to the customer.
Andrew Ackley, a lawyer for the claimants, said that under this auditing system, the garbage collectors could conceivably report and bill for extra garbage at every house they stop at and they would be audited at 100% accuracy, because they would match every instance of extra garbage that city inspectors found.
The claims also argue that SPU obscures the extra charges by including them with water and sewer bills — which vary from month to month — making it tougher for ratepayers to spot when an extra garbage fee is included.
SPU also puts the extra garbage fees on the last page of a three-page bill. They come after a page that’s totally boilerplate, never changing, just listing phone numbers to call, and seemingly indicating that the variable or personalized part of the bill is over.
Customers can call 206-684-3000 to complain about a charge and have it removed, but only back two billing cycles, the claim says.
"The City uses data it knows to be inaccurate a significant percentage of time, obscures extra solid waste charges from customers, and has implemented an unreasonably tedious and ineffective dispute process for customers who notice inaccurate charges, the claim says.
© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.