Opinion: Washington's tax buffet is open — and it's all you can eat

Posted

Lawmakers in Washington state have accomplished something remarkable. They've made historic tax increases look inadequate.

Governor Bob Ferguson is now projecting a $4 billion budget gap for the upcoming biennium. You read that right: lawmakers in Washington state have spent $4 billion more than they have.

How is that possible, given the fact that Washington just adopted historic tax increases? Higher business taxes. Expanded sales taxes. Higher capital gains taxes. A new unconstitutional income tax.

And still, Olympia is checking the couch cushions. At some point, taxpayers are entitled to ask whether the problem is the size of their contribution or the size of Olympia’s appetite.

Consider what happened just last year. Lawmakers decided to approve a package of major tax increases projected to generate approximately $9.4 billion.

And it still wasn't large enough to meet the spending. In fact, over the past seven bienniums, Washington lawmakers have increased spending a whopping 157%. Over the past four bienniums, lawmakers are averaging an increase of almost ten billion dollars every two years. This is not sustainable.

You don't have to take our word for it either. Two former Democratic governors have been trying to get their own party’s attention.



Former Gov. Christine Gregoire put it plainly: “I would suggest we don’t really have an income problem; we have a spending problem.” She also criticized the practice of layering additional taxes and regulations onto an increasingly unpredictable business climate.

Former Gov. Gary Locke has delivered a similar warning. In an October interview, he criticized the cycle of raising taxes, declaring the money insufficient, and raising them again without adequately examining whether existing programs work. His description of where that leaves voters: “The promises are not being kept, and we’re just being taxed like crazy.”

These are former Democratic governors who actually had to make the numbers work. The current governor says he won't propose additional taxes in his upcoming budget and that the new income tax will "stabilize" finances.

Good luck with that. The state is likely to see less revenue than it projects from the new tax, as wealthier citizens flee the state for better tax and business climates. Both Montana and Idaho are proving attractive to entrepreneurs who are now questioning their future in the Evergreen state.

But Olympia likely won't get the message until it's too late. And until then, citizens are going to get stuck with the bill.

Chris Cargill is the President of Mountain States Policy Center, an independent free market think tank based in Idaho, Montana, Wyoming and Washington. Online at mountainstatespolicy.org.