Julie McDonald: Changes prompt Lewis County museum to question future

Posted

With expenses increasing and income dropping, the president of the Lewis County Historical Society says he’s worried about how to keep the local museum’s doors open in the future.

Since 1973, Lewis County has paid Burlington Northern a dollar a year to lease the old Chehalis train depot for use as the Lewis County Historical Museum, and the county has provided janitorial and landscaping maintenance of the building and grounds.

But in early September, county officials proposed that the historical society instead lease and maintain the property.

Rather than a dollar a year, the cost is more likely to be $5,000 annually, said Peter Lahmann, society president, plus $1,750 to transfer the name on the lease. The society also would be responsible for maintaining and insuring the building and paying the estimated $6,000 a year in property tax. The county covers those costs now, estimated at $54,000 a year, through tourism funds.

“I’m thinking, ‘we have one employee,’” Lahmann said last week. “They answer the phone and the door. You know, they do everything.”

Impetus for the change is acceptance of a $150,000 Washington state Department of Commerce grant to replace the roof on the 1912 building at 599 NW Front Way in Chehalis.

“As a requirement of that grant, the museum must occupy the building and provide services to the public for 10 years,” Lewis County Commissioner Lindsey Pollock said. “The county is requesting that the museum enter into a 10-year lease with the building’s owner, Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad, to satisfy the grant requirement. If the museum does not fulfill the 10-year requirement, the Department of Commerce may require that Lewis County repay the grant.”

Back in the 1970s, railroad officials hesitated to lease the building to a new untested nonprofit, but since the museum has been operating for 50 years, they are willing to work with the historical society, according to Becky Butler, budget director and interim county manager.

Lahmann responded to the county’s proposal, saying the society didn’t see how that would work, but county officials said they’re moving forward anyway. Changes will take place after the first of the year. The grant gives local officials until June 2027 to use the money for roof replacement.

“The county is fully committed to assisting the museum wherever we can, including serving as the administrator and guarantor of the Commerce grant,” Pollock said.

In September, when Lahmann described the proposal as county officials’ attempt to step away from partnering with the historical society, Pollock said the historical society could maintain the museum on a faster timeline and at lower cost than county government.

“On the maintenance cost, simply put, we cost much more than private labor,” Lewis County Commissioner Scott Brummer said last week. “Our facilities department has major overhead costs and significantly higher wages. I am confident the museum can take care of the newly repaired building for a fraction of the cost for us to do it.”

While the historical society wants a self-sustaining museum, Lahmann said, it’s still recovering from the embezzlement and overspending of its $460,000 endowment fund in 2011 by Debbie Knapp, former museum director.

Since then, through rebuilding efforts, the endowment has grown to about $500,000, but that’s not nearly enough for interest on the principal and museum admission fees to cover operating costs.

“If we run for a year or two and have to pull money out of the endowment to cover monthly expenses and stuff, we’re just slowly, you know, dying one drip at a time,” Lahmann said.

Although the museum already pays for its utilities, insurance costs through the county are much more affordable than what the society would pay in the marketplace, he said. The society’s original agreement with the county states that if the museum closes, all the artifacts in its collection go to the county.

Part of the society’s financial woes stem from a cutback in the amount received from lodging taxes, which are collected on overnight stays at hotels, motels, bed and breakfasts, and Airbnb rentals. The Lodging Tax Advisory Committee (LTAC), made up of citizens, allocates that money to tourism-related nonprofits, government entities or other tax-exempt organizations.



“This year’s committee was faced with $2.4 million in grant asks with only $1 million to spend,” said Brummer, who coordinates the county’s LTAC. “They made the decision to either cut all or significant amounts of funding to museums, visitor centers, and chambers of commerce. They were clear that they do not see these entities fulfilling the requirement that LTAC dollars be used to promote ‘heads in beds.’ That was their decision to make.”

He and Pollock both noted that Lewis County commissioners have no authority to override any LTAC decisions, but they can add extra money, such as to offset losses by museums. Brummer said the county plans to add $200,000 from the collected taxes to the committee-awarded amounts.

He said the Lewis County Historical Society requested $50,000 but received $30,000, with no money for maintenance and operations. With the additional money, Brummer said, the society will have the flexibility to build a budget that covers operating costs.

“We value and support our museums and rich history in Lewis County and will continue to do everything we can within the funding allocations available to insure they remain a part of our heritage,” Brummer said. “It is, however, necessary that LTAC not be solely relied upon as they are a ‘grant’ based appropriation.”

Last year, the historic Claquato Church, which was owned by Lewis County and allowed to fall into disrepair, was declared surplus and put on the auction block. Fortunately, the Claquato Cemetery Board bought the 1858 building for $5,000 in October 2025 and began restoring it.

“I fundamentally believe that county government should do its best to let private entities hold our museums and historical places,” Brummer said. “The challenges with government and priority spending make it difficult to keep and maintain them.

“I would use the Claquato church as a recent example of private ownership doing it better!”

In a digital society where so many keep their faces glued to electronic screens, perhaps people no longer see a need for historical museums that display artifacts from bygone eras.

I hope that’s not the case. I have learned so much visiting museums across the United States, Canada and Europe that preserve the past for future generations.

Lahmann said his fourth-grade teacher at Washington Elementary School, Serena Armentrout, a descendant of local pioneers, sparked his interest in history.

I was volunteering to help with school field trips at the Lewis County Historical Museum when I saw a placard about Matilda Koontz Jackson, spurring my desire to tell the story of this remarkable pioneer in books, both nonfiction, “Washington Territory’s Grand Lady,” and historical fiction, “The Reluctant Pioneer.”

It’s important to preserve the past, but I guess the question is how to do so.

As Spanish-American philosopher and writer George Santayana famously put it, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

•••

Julie McDonald, a personal historian from Toledo, may be reached at memoirs@chaptersoflife.com.