I find myself questioning the message of Mossyrock Superintendent Effie J. Dean being presented in a recent letter to the editor versus the experiences many of us have actually had.
Dr. Dean speaks of candor, open doors, direct answers, transparency, collaboration and respectful disagreement. These are all wonderful commitments. However, I believe the community deserves to ask an important question: Where was this commitment to open communication when parents and community members were actually seeking answers?
It’s easy to write about keeping an open door. It’s considerably harder to demonstrate it when the questions being asked are uncomfortable.
I have personally attempted to communicate with Dr. Dean regarding legitimate concerns involving our school district. I have sent emails, requested clarification, sought accountability and asked questions that I believe any concerned parent or taxpayer should feel comfortable asking. Unfortunately, my experiences have not reflected the open communication she now describes.
Consider the communication surrounding the school bus accident involving 13 students. Parents were left without direct notification from the district, despite an incident involving their children. I personally had to question why I was learning about an incident through my child rather than through the school district. When I raised that concern, I received explanations that did not resolve the discrepancies in communication or provide the reassurance parents deserved.
That is not a disagreement between adults. That is a failure of communication involving the safety and wellbeing of our children.
There have also been concerns surrounding administrative decisions, employees placed on paid administrative leave, district policies, public records and the transparency of district leadership. When community members ask questions about these matters, they should not automatically be characterized as creating conflict or taking attention away from students.
Asking questions is not creating problems. Demanding accountability is not being disruptive. And questioning leadership is not the same as being against our schools.
I find it particularly interesting that Dr. Dean now emphasizes welcoming hard questions about district decisions and public spending, when my own attempts to obtain information and clarification have resulted in considerable frustration, unanswered questions and eventually a cease-and-desist demand. I want to be clear that my intention was never to create personal conflict. I have even communicated my willingness to withdraw my outstanding records requests and move forward. That should demonstrate that I am not interested in endless confrontation. I am interested in a school district where people can ask reasonable questions without feeling that they are becoming the problem simply for asking them.
And while I welcome the announcement of quarterly community events, I hope these events become more than opportunities for the district to present its accomplishments and distribute information. I hope they become genuine opportunities for parents and taxpayers to ask difficult questions and receive meaningful answers.
A community survey and a new strategic plan are valuable tools, but neither replaces accountability for decisions already made or answers to questions that have already been asked.
Dr. Dean says our children are watching how adults treat one another. I agree. They are also watching how leaders respond when they are questioned, how people in positions of authority accept responsibility, and whether the values we teach them are actually practiced by the adults leading their schools.
We teach our children to take responsibility for their actions, communicate honestly, own their mistakes, and treat others with respect. Those expectations should not disappear when someone becomes a superintendent.
I don’t believe the answer is to silence disagreement, discourage questions, or ask everyone to simply move on. The answer is to address the concerns that brought us here in the first place.
I love this community. I have a personal connection to Mossyrock Schools, and my children are part of this district. I want our schools to succeed. I want our teachers supported, our students given opportunities, our extracurricular programs strengthened, and our community proud of the education being provided.
But wanting better for our district sometimes means acknowledging that things are not where they need to be.
Dr. Dean asks the community to return its focus to what matters most. I would argue that many of us have never lost that focus. We have been asking questions because we care about what happens inside those classrooms and within the district that serves our children.
You cannot ask a community to trust an open door when its previous attempts to walk through that door have gone unanswered.
Transparency is not a quarterly event. Communication is not a promise made in a newspaper column. Accountability is not something reserved for the people who disagree with you.
If Dr. Dean genuinely wants to rebuild trust, I encourage her to start by addressing the questions that have already been asked, acknowledging where communication has fallen short, and demonstrating through her actions that every parent and taxpayer deserves to be heard.
Our students deserve better than adults arguing about conflict. They deserve leadership that is willing to take responsibility, listen when it is uncomfortable, and lead by example.
That is the kind of leadership I want to see in Mossyrock.
Natasha Hernandez
Mossyrock