A corporate income tax in Washington? Top Democratic lawmaker floats the idea

Posted

Fresh off this month’s election victory for Washington’s new “millionaires tax,” a top state lawmaker is floating the possibility of another income tax — this one on businesses.

Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen, an architect of the 9.9% high-earners tax on households, thinks Washington should “demolish” its complicated business and occupation, or B&O, tax, and replace it with a new corporate income tax.  

The proposal is still in the idea stage, with no legislation likely before 2028, Pedersen said in an interview last week. The Seattle Democrat said he’s quietly discussing it with other lawmakers and progressive groups, and that several “major employers” have given “a qualified thumbs up on the project.”

Pedersen said the switch would be “revenue neutral,” meaning it wouldn’t raise more money for the state. Instead, he said, the goal is a simpler tax code that is more in line with other states and falls more evenly across different types of businesses. 

But moving from a B&O tax to a corporate income tax would be a heavy lift.

Income taxes are still effectively unconstitutional in Washington, pending the outcome of a current legal challenge against the high-earners tax. 

The B&O tax is a big moneymaker. It accounts for about 19% of state tax revenue, or around $7 billion annually. That’s roughly twice what’s expected from tax on millionaire earners, meaning any new corporate income tax would likely need a double digit tax rate, based on previous state estimates.

And despite Pedersen’s revenue-neutral assurances, some business groups worry that, given recurring state budget gaps, the Democrat-controlled Legislature would use the swap as another opportunity to raise tax revenue, much as they just did with the high-earners tax. 

“There’s a lot of tax fatigue right now,” Brad Smith, vice chair and president at Microsoft, and a veteran of state tax debates, said last week. “We’re only a week past the vote on the last tax – it’s a little early to start talking about the next one.”

For decades, various advocates have wanted to replace Washington’s nearly century-old system of B&O taxes with other kinds of taxes, including some version of a corporate income tax used now in more than 40 states. 

Where a corporate income tax is generally levied on company profits, the B&O tax applies to overall revenues. 

Critics say that, among other problems, this structure penalizes industries such as food service and grocery retail that often have high sales volumes but thin profits.

Washington’s B&O tax “is a punitive, economically inefficient tax that harms lower margin businesses (and) harms Washington consumers who are purchasing extensively from lower-margin businesses,” said Jared Walczak, a senior fellow at the Tax Foundation, a think tank that typically favors lower taxes. 

Replacing it with a corporate income tax, if done right, would be “a significant reform,” Walczak added. 

Until now, hopes for such a change have been thin. 

Income taxes have been effectively banned in Washington since a 1933 state Supreme Court ruling, and the high court struck down a 4% corporate income tax in 1951. Voters have rejected past proposals for income taxes, including for a corporate income tax, and bills in the Legislature calling for corporate income taxes have languished.

Circumstances changed this year when Democratic lawmakers pushed through the tax on household income above $1 million annually.

Opponents tried to repeal the tax with Initiative 645, on the November ballot. The failure of that initiative effort shows voters are ready to embrace at least a narrowly targeted income tax, according to the tax’s supporters. 

The high-earners tax faces a lawsuit, but proponents expect the state Supreme Court will uphold the new levy by overturning the 1933 decision, which would potentially open the door to a corporate income tax. 

“It’s time for us to take advantage of the flexibility that a (court) win in the millionaires tax will offer us in moving away from this one-of-a-kind approach to business taxation and toward a more normal approach,” Pedersen said last week.

Hugh Spitzer, a retired University of Washington law professor and expert on the state tax system, thinks a corporate income tax could strike the right political balance.



“It’s not going to bother the general public,” Spitzer said. “And it could be very popular with the business community, because businesses really dislike the B&O tax.”

But, Spitzer cautions, the business community is likely to withhold support until they see the fine print – especially the proposed tax rate.

And that’s where things could get tough, says the Tax Foundation’s Walczak.

Because Washington relies so heavily on the B&O, Walczak said, the corporate income tax rate needed to replace it “could be eye-wateringly high.” 

A state Department of Revenue analysis in 2020 examined a corporate tax along these lines and found Washington would need to set the rate at 15.8% to replace B&O tax revenues in the 2017-2019 biennium, which were around 40% lower than today’s. 

For comparison, in states with a corporate income tax, the average top rate is 6.6%, and ranges from a 2% flat rate in North Carolina to a top marginal rate of 11.5% in New Jersey, according to the Tax Foundation. 

Pedersen said it’s “way too early” to know what Washington’s corporate tax rate might be.

Even without knowing, though, business leaders seem skeptical.

“We think it’s extremely unlikely that the state would rewrite our tax code and that the total revenue for the state of Washington would somehow be less than it is under the B&O regime,” said Morgan Irwin, vice president for government affairs with the Association of Washington Business.

For all businesses’ complaints about the inequities of the B&O system, many would be reluctant to move to a new framework, especially if it meant giving up any of the scores of B&O exemptions they’ve lobbied to secure over the years. 

When Washington businesses are surveyed “about alternatives to the B&O tax in the past, folks have preferred to stick with the devil they know than to try something new,” said Patrick Connor, who directs the Washington state office of the National Federation of Independent Business.

Pedersen pushed back on suggestions that the corporate income tax would be just another tax hike. 

“The objective is to improve the business climate” with a fairer, more efficient tax system, he said. 

Concerns extend beyond the business community.

Some progressive and labor groups want an even broader tax overhaul — including reductions in “regressive” taxes, especially sales tax, that fall disproportionately on lower earners. 

And some on the left think lawmakers will have little choice but to raise even more money for state costs like healthcare and education and to make up for losses in federal funding.

Joe Kendo, chief of staff at the Washington State Labor Council, agrees that the B&O tax needs to be retired, but thinks it would be a “lost opportunity,” if future tax debates in the Legislature focus “solely on revenue neutrality.”

“Revenue neutrality was not what the voters endorsed in this most recent election” when they rejected I-645, he said. “They endorsed restructuring and revenue positivity … with an eye toward sustaining and improving public services.”

Pedersen acknowledged that corporate income tax discussions could get thorny. He noted that lawmakers would need to grapple not just with high-profile issues like rates, but also more technical matters, such as how the new tax might interact with existing state and local taxes.

“There are a lot of moving parts,” Pedersen said. 

That’s one reason he isn’t expecting legislation any sooner than 2028 and probably not until 2029. “There are a whole bunch of people who are ready to have this conversation,” Pedersen said. “But it is a complicated conversation.”