Washington Initiative 638 supporters seek to defend it in court

Posted

A nonprofit organization affiliated with some student athletes in Washington is asking to help defend Initiative 638 against a legal challenge, saying it can make arguments the state’s own attorneys can’t and won’t.

Female Athletes United has filed a motion to intervene in the case against the hotly debated initiative, which is meant to ban transgender girls from girls school sports and which 56% of voters approved in the Nov. 3 election.

The national nonprofit, represented by attorneys from a conservative Christian legal organization, says it has members who play girls sports in Washington and can bring their personal experiences to bear on the case.

The Washington members include cross-country runners who competed this fall against a transgender student athlete from Camas High School.

“(Female Athletes United)’s members can tell the Court firsthand what happens” when transgender girls compete in girls sports, where they may outperform some cisgender girls, attorneys from Alliance Defending Freedom wrote Friday.

The intervention request came after Washington Attorney General Nick Brown announced he had appointed an outside law firm to defend I-638 on behalf of the state, rather than have his office’s attorneys handle the case.

A judge will decide whether Female Athletes United can join the high-profile and increasingly complicated King County Superior Court battle.

The lawsuit was filed Nov. 9 by the state teachers union, student-athlete parents who oppose I-638 and a nonprofit that assists transgender youth.

Attorneys for Legal Voice, the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington and Pacific Law Group are representing the plaintiffs, who include parents of transgender and cisgender girls in Seattle Public Schools.

The legal tussle follows months of intense debate over I-638, which was advanced by hedge fund manager Brian Heywood’s Republican-aligned political action committee and opposed by Democratic leaders.

I-638 is meant to reverse a longstanding policy in Washington that allows students to compete on sports teams that align with their gender identities.

Supporters contend the initiative will ensure fairness in girls sports. Opponents allege it will discriminate against transgender girls by excluding them and discriminate against all girls by forcing them to prove their sex before they can play.

The plaintiffs suing over I-638 want to block the initiative from taking effect Dec. 3 as scheduled. They say the initiative violates provisions of the state constitution related to privacy, equal rights and equal education.

Besides Female Athletes United, other parties could also seek to intervene.

AG’s decision

Washington is the defendant in the lawsuit against I-638, and the attorney general’s office is the agency that defends lawsuits against the state.

Brown, a Democrat, made waves last week with his choice to appoint the outside law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner to handle the defense.

This may be the first time a Washington attorney general has used outside counsel to defend a voter-approved initiative. Hugh Spitzer, a University of Washington law professor and expert on the state constitution, said he wasn’t sure. A spokesperson for Brown’s office described the move as without precedent “as best we can tell or that anyone in the office can recall.”



In an initial statement last week, Brown characterized the outsourcing action as a way to fulfill his duty to defend I-638 while he simultaneously works to protect transgender peoples’ rights in other cases. Brown’s office subsequently expanded on that rationale in an email.

“The special circumstance here is that we are actively litigating multiple cases on behalf of the state defending transgender rights,” including lawsuits against President Donald Trump’s administration and other cases in which the state has been sued,” Brown spokesperson Mike Faulk wrote.

“We are not yet certain exactly what arguments will need to be made in defense of I-638, or the extent to which they (may) conflict with any arguments we are currently making in other cases,” he added. “But we could not wait to see how the case developed to have someone get started.”

Female Athletes United is raising similar issues in saying it should be allowed to help defend the initiative. The nonprofit holds that blocking I-638 and keeping Washington’s trans-inclusive school sports policy in place would violate federal law, because Title IX protects girls’ sports. But it says it doubts the state’s attorneys will be willing to make that argument.

“Doing so would force the State to admit liability for its current practice” and contradict what Brown’s office has maintained in another case, the attorneys for Female Athletes United asserted in their intervention motion.

Alliance Defending Freedom is involved in that other lawsuit, which it filed against Washington's trans-inclusive school sports policy earlier this year.

Advocates react

Brown was a partner at Pacific Law Group before being elected attorney general. Faulk, his spokesperson, said that link had “absolutely nothing to do with our decision” to appoint outside attorneys to defend I-638.

Heywood’s PAC, Let’s Go Washington, criticized Brown last week for appointing Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, saying attorneys for the St. Louis-based firm with a Seattle office have in past years worked on cases for transgender rights, including with the American Civil Liberties Union.

“This is the law firm you would hire if you wanted to strike 638 down, not defend it,” said Darren Littell, the PAC’s executive director.

A spokesperson for the ACLU of Washington declined to comment on Brown’s choice to appoint outside counsel.

Michael Woodward, executive director of TRACTION, a Seattle nonprofit that advocates for transgender people, said he understands Brown’s decision.

The attorney general's office is responsible for defending the state; and declining to defend I-683, as California once did for an initiative that banned same-sex marriage, wouldn’t automatically invalidate it, Woodward noted. In California, intervenors were allowed to defend the law.

“What matters more” is what the attorneys Brown has appointed actually argue, Woodward said, hoping they don’t narrow or weaken the state’s protections for transgender people in the course of defending I-638.

The trans rights leader said he hopes the judge in the case will stop the initiative from taking effect. “I believe I-638 is unconstitutional, and I'm confident the courts will strike it down. But thousands of young people across the state shouldn't have to endure harm while we wait.”

© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.