Seattle City Council primed to pass budget that adds millions in contentious spending

Posted

The Seattle City Council is set to vote this week on a budget that adds tens of millions of dollars in new to spending in 2027 to what Mayor Katie Wilson proposed in September.

The budget process was more contentious than it has been in recent years, with some council members taking issue with Wilson's $9.1 billion spending plan, her first since taking office, that focused heavily on her priorities. The plan from a self-described socialist took many by surprise by cutting spending and avoiding new taxes while plugging a $175 million deficit.

She said she was creating a sustainable budget. It didn't rely on one-time funding to pay for projects that were intended to last more than one year. And it didn't lean as heavily on a tax that was designed to pay for housing and climate initiatives but has been raided every year since its creation to plug holes.

But many council members, including Councilmember Dan Strauss who leads the council's budget committee, argued the council has the ultimate power over the budget and would determine which city services deserved priority for public dollars.

Changing the budget is no simple manner. Wilson's budget ran to 735 pages, and the council members' amendments were described in a 2,835-page agenda packet.

Over hours of discussion and endless votes during two full days on the dais, council members agreed to add millions in spending, finding unanimous agreement on a package of well over 100 amendments. Still, members had no shortage of discord, notably on votes limiting what the city's payroll tax can be spent on, and whether the council should be held to the same budget-balancing rules as the mayor.

Other votes restored dollars to council member priorities, focused on the funding of police surveillance cameras, firefighter overtime and more.

The council will vote on the final budget package Friday.

Leaning on payroll tax

When Wilson delivered her budget, she said she wasn't raising taxes because doing so during a grim economy would come with great risks."

Even so, her plan used the city’s payroll tax — JumpStart — to fund homelessness services, a role beyond its original purpose. The temptation to pilfer JumpStart, which brings in about $400 million in revenue, has been strong, especially as the city's budget started growing holes. Wilson’s predecessor, Bruce Harrell, first proposed doing so, eventually taking the guardrails off JumpStart spending entirely.

When council members added millions to Wilson's proposal in spending on services and programs they deemed important, they deepened the reliance on JumpStart.

Wilson's plan envisioned saving some of the tax's revenue in future years and increase JumpStart's stabilization reserve fund to $31 million by the end of 2028. The council's budget will spend it all but protects the reserves fund's balance of $20 million.

Members showed some hesitation in relying on the tax by throwing their support behind a request from Councilmember Dionne Foster, which would require the city budget office to develop a plan to appropriate 50% of annual JumpStart revenue by 2033 to affordable housing and the Equitable Development Initiative, a city program designed to stop displacement, reduce systemic inequities and help build generational wealth for marginalized communities.

Only Councilmembers Bob Kettle and Maritza Rivera voted against Foster's idea.

Balancing one-time adds

Part of the debate about using JumpStart the way it has been is that it means the programs and projects it pays for will only be funded for one year. Because JumpStart's revenue changes year to year, it cannot be allocated to supporting ongoing projects that need reliable funding.

As council members cycled through their amendments, they argued about what constituted a one-time cost and what were ongoing expenses.

Those arguments were partly informed by a memo sent to them this month by Aly Pennucci, the city's budget director who largely built Wilson's spending plan.

"A major driver of the structural budget deficit has been the practice of using one-time funding to pay for ongoing items," Pennucci wrote.

Pennucci said if all of the one-time council additions to the 2027 budget become permanent, the city would have a $41 million deficit in 2029. Wilson's budget had no deficit projected in 2029, the first time in years deficits weren't predicted into the future.

Wilson's office said Tuesday that the council's proposed budget has more than $20 million in spending that is not funded in 2028 — setting up another painful budget season next year.

"We owe it to City departments and community partners to plan strategically and long-term to ensure their work is supported and their needs are met," Wilson said in a statement.



The council nodded to the ongoing budget issues by unanimously approving an ordinance that would require the mayor to submit balanced six-year financial plans for both the general fund and JumpStart fund and require the mayor's budget writers to identify spending reductions for future years.

Wilson said in her Tuesday statement that she supported a sister proposal from Foster that would have had the council follow similar budget balancing rules, and prevent council budget changes from worsening the city's long-term financial outlook. State law already requires council to pass yearly balanced budgets.

"If a standard is good enough to ask for a different branch of government to meet it, I believe that it's fair to ask ourselves to fall in line with the same standard," Foster said.

Members praised the intent, but voted it down 4-5, with Councilmembers Joy Hollingsworth, Rob Saka, Kettle, Rivera and Strauss voting against it.

"The mayor creates their budget in private with no public discussion, no public hearings and no transparency," Rivera said, adding that the council has a tougher role on the budget.

Saka said the council should retain "maximum flexibility" to modify the mayor's budget vision in response to community priorities and needs.

Strauss noted the mayor has five months to build a budget, while the council has five weeks.

"I don't need a law to do what's right," Strauss said. "I don't need a law or executive order to tell me how to do my job well."

Strauss said he included budget requests, big and small, from each council member.

Strauss' package included a request from Hollingsworth for $3.2 million to support to organizations that will help to revitalize Seattle's Central District and Southeast Seattle neighborhoods; $475,000 for cleaning and improvements in West Seattle business districts from Saka; and $50,000 for the Georgetown farmers market requested by Foster.

Saka also won $1 million for each council member to spend in their district on transportation safety projects, a fund Wilson had cut from her budget.

It also included 12 amendments of his own with one-time funding, totaling more than $4.8 million. Five were explicitly focused on Ballard to the tune of $1.4 million, including $500,000 in one-time spending for murals and mural tours in the Ballard Brewery District, and $150,000 to encourage foot traffic in Ballard's business core during the winter that entails an illuminated statue of Jimothy, the Seattle raccoon who became "internet famous this summer.

Most of the Ballard amendments were approved and included in the budget.

Police and fire

The council also focused on public safety spending in their amendments.

The council voted to fund $7.1 million in overtime Wilson left out of her proposal. The council also put $150,000 toward a study to build a new fire station in South Lake Union, and $850,000 toward the repair and maintenance of fireboat Leschi.

The council also considered a number of amendments and legislation related to the Police Department.

One brought by Foster focused on the $13 million in wages the city overpaid to department employees this year. Foster sought to dedicate whatever money was recovered from those repayments to affordable housing. The legislation floundered in a tie vote, but Strauss said it would be taken up again later this week.

Councilmember Alexis Mercedes Rinck attempted to limit the expansion of surveillance technology, following Wilson's approval last week of a planned expansion, while adding safeguards against risks to privacy and civil liberties.

Her proposal, which would have restricted funds for the technology until certain protections had been institutionalized, was voted down.

Kettle's proposal to fund the city's Technology Assisted Crime Prevention Program with $4.1 million, however, passed.

The program includes closed-circuit TV camera, Seattle Department of Transportation traffic-camera feeds and technology and staffing at the Real Time Crime Center.

© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.