Sean Swope commentary: Proposing a book rating system for reading material at Timberland Regional Library

Posted

Navigating through the extensive archives of a library should be an enlightening and secure journey for all patrons, especially for our young readers who are starting to explore the vast realms of literature. As a Lewis County commissioner, a taxpayer contributing to the Timberland Regional Library and, most crucially, as a concerned father, I propose a policy that seeks not to restrict, but to guide this educational journey through a well-structured book rating system.

The recent argument against the book rating policy leans heavily on the Freedom to Read statement, which has been a stalwart in advocating for unbridled access to a spectrum of literary works. While this is both revered and essential, it is imperative to recognize that providing a framework through a Timberland Regional Library book rating system policy does not equate to stifling intellectual freedom, but rather, it illuminates a path that ensures content is appropriate across diverse age demographics.

The role of a library isn't just to offer unrestrained access but to ensure that such access is navigated with informed choices, particularly for our younger patrons. The proposed rating system aims to strike a harmony between maintaining intellectual freedom and ensuring that our children explore age-appropriate materials. This isn't about censorship, but about providing a transparent, clear guideline to assist readers and their guardians in selecting material that aligns with their comfort and developmental level.

With an annual collective contribution of around $3.5 million from Lewis County to Timberland Regional Library, taxpayers like myself are not merely funders but stakeholders in the educational and social fiber of our community. Our investment interweaves with a commitment to ensure that the library remains a sanctuary for all readers, fostering an environment where exploration is not hindered but is embarked upon with informed discernment.

Given the privilege of appointing two board members to the Timberland Regional Library Board of Trustees, my advocacy for this policy does not stem from a desire to control or limit access but arises from a responsibility to safeguard and enhance the reading journey for all. The board, representing the community, plays a pivotal role in ensuring the library sustains its commitment to intellectual freedom, inclusivity, and access to diverse literature. The proposed book rating system adheres to these principles, offering clear insights into content suitability and facilitating informed choices, without barricading access to diverse literature.

Moreover, it's noteworthy that the executive director has not engaged in discussions with the commissioners since the introduction of this policy proposal, demonstrating resistance to collaborative dialogue on this matter.



At 10 a.m. Tuesday, Oct. 10, I will be presenting the case for this imperative rating system at the Board of County Commissioners meeting. Your presence, insights and support during the meeting — whether in-person or virtually — would significantly bolster this endeavor. You can attend via Zoom by visiting https://lewiscountywa.gov/.

For those interested in the specific details of the draft policy, it is available for review and feedback on the Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/vote4swope. Your insights and perspectives on this matter are valuable and I encourage you to explore the policy and share your thoughts.

It's pivotal to acknowledge that providing a roadmap through a structured rating system enhances, not impedes, the pursuit of knowledge. Unreserved access and systematized guidance are not mutually exclusive, but can harmoniously live together, ensuring the library remains a beacon of knowledge, exploration and inclusive access to all.

In conclusion, our mission is collective — to uphold the integrity and freedom of our reading spaces, ensuring they are navigated with wisdom, understanding and a conscientious approach, cherishing the unwavering spirit of intellectual freedom while embarking on a journey through the rich, diverse tapestry of literature.

Sean Swope a Lewis County commissioner. 

Editor's note: For a recent commentary on this topic from Timberland Regional Library Director of Content and Access Andrea Heisel, visit https://tinyurl.com/2hx4yyss.