Letter writer Mr. Meekhof is wrong. A no vote doesn’t protect anything except an income-tax plan that is designed to open the door to income taxes on everyone.
Reporting from The Center Square confirms this strategy. Their records show Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen wrote that a court challenge would give the Washington Supreme Court a chance to revisit what he called the “bad decisions” of treating income as property. If that ruling was overturned, lawmakers could then enact a progressive income tax with a simple majority vote.
Present circumstances appear to describe that strategy exactly: pass a defective income tax (done), that requires a constitutional challenge (done), and have the court rule it must apply to everyone. That’s the legality Olympia needs.
A YES vote stops the plan cold. The constitutional challenge was filed in April. Just as predicted. The legal fight has begun; the question isn’t should millionaires should pay more; it’s whether Washington voters fall for the scheme.
Washington’s Constitution requires taxes on the same class of property to be uniform, put simply, the same rate for everyone, not a higher rate for some and none for others. The Supreme Court 1932 ruling is the problem; the court treated income as property; this is the rub. In 1934, voters voted down a constitutional amendment to authorize an income tax. This is a sneaky way around a public vote on an income tax on everyone.
The current law only taxes income above $1 million. That is illegal. Supporters want the law struck down for not being applied to everyone but kept on the books. As long as the tax is ruled legal, voters will have no way back.
Then Olympia changes the wording to be legal, and they can impose a mandatory income tax at whatever level they choose with a simple majority vote. The law is being hidden under verbiage to sound dire, complex and punish the rich.
Why did Olympia try to stop the ballot process for this law only? Politicians design laws to be confusing. A confused mind always says no. That is the risk voters should understand.
A YES means we refuse a universal income tax on every Washingtonian’s paycheck, retirement/pension account and death benefit in the state.
The Climate Commitment Act is not a tax, but our gasoline and electric bills hide the increase. We may not have an income tax yet, but with what we pay now in hidden taxes places us 13th in the nation.
This is exactly how California got to where it is now.
Rommel said, “A risk is a chance you take; if it fails you can recover. A gamble is a chance taken; if it fails, recovery is impossible.”
I 645 is not a risk. It is a gamble. Once in place, it will not go away and voters deserve to know the whole story before they place their bet.
Vote YES. Repeal the law.
Ray Anderson
Ethel