Homeless people now stay in Washington state shelters for months. Are they tenants?

Posted

The call to police should have been routine. A manager at the homeless shelter in the old Days Inn off Interstate 5 had asked for help in removing a former client — typically a last resort for when someone refuses to leave.

But when four officers arrived, Cody Hamilton had a legal aid attorney on speakerphone warning it could be an illegal eviction.

Unsure what to do, the police stood in the hallway while one officer consulted Lacey’s city attorney. Footage from their body-worn cameras shows the shelter manager in disbelief. Evictions are reserved for tenants, often thought of as long-term residents who sign leases and pay rent — the people in the old hotel don’t do either of those things.

“Nobody's ever been a resident because this is a shelter,” the manager said.

Yet, that spring afternoon last year, the police left Hamilton in his room.

One legal aid attorney has exposed a gray area in state law, created when cities shifted to shelters that give people their own space, often with a door, lock and key. These shelters, many in refurbished hotels and tiny homes, were designed to help people coming off the streets feel more stable and secure, but some people are now staying for months or years as they wait for permanent housing that’s rarely available.

Carrie Graf, the Thurston County attorney with the nonprofit Northwest Justice Project, which provides free legal help for low-income residents, said these shelters have become people’s homes.

“If you have a door that locks,” she said, “you are not just in an overnight shelter. You have a place you return to every night that is yours.”

She has filed lawsuits on behalf of people like Hamilton. Already, she has disrupted how Thurston County providers operate several hundred beds of shelter. Instead of kicking out people who violate the rules, shelters now seek approval from a judge in a longer, more expensive process.

Hundreds more beds across Washington, including much of King County’s near-capacity shelter system, could be subject to the same rules if Graf’s legal challenges — or new similar cases — gain traction in higher courts.

Providers warn that treating shelters as housing could turn their mission on its head, ultimately leading to fewer people getting help.

“You're basically changing the whole premise of what's an emergency shelter,” said Sharon Lee, executive director of the Low Income Housing Institute.


‘I wasn’t able to have a word’

The old Days Inn opened in 2023 as Maple Court, a 118-room shelter, part of a wave of public investment in shelters that gave people their own rooms and allowed them to stay for extended periods.

Communities had already been experimenting with individual units through tiny homes — Olympia started building its first tiny homes in 2019, eventually expanding to about 150. Then the pandemic hit, bringing fears of COVID-19 outbreaks in shelters where many people shared the same sleeping space, and state and local leaders began buying hotels where each homeless person could have a separate room.

Officials said they hoped calmer, more private shelter spaces would not only keep people safe from disease but allow them to steady their lives, which research eventually showed they did. A study conducted by University of Washington researchers found they improved residents’ sleep, hygiene and mental health.

“This gives people a roof and a stable way to deal with their problems,” said then-Gov. Jay Inslee at the opening ceremony for Maple Court, according to a story in The Olympian. “It is a first step toward a permanent solution.”

But that permanent solution remains on the horizon for many. The most common route to housing for people coming out of homelessness is government-subsidized apartments, and those are almost always full. In King County, such buildings were at 94% capacity in 2025, according to regional data.

Meanwhile, many wait — and wait — in these new shelters. The average length of stay in King County’s shelters has more than doubled in the past six years to 175 days in 2025. In some shelters, the average is more than a year.

What concerned Graf, the attorney in Thurston County, was that these more private spaces and longer stays didn’t translate into any more protections when shelters decided people needed to leave.

Cody Hamilton’s case was one example.

He had lived in the Maple Court shelter with his girlfriend for a year and a half. One day, months before the April police call, he said he needed a key to his room and staff gave him the wrong one. He said it broke off in the door, leaving his dog trapped inside. And when he asked for help, he said the staff told him to figure it out himself.

That led to him kicking in the door, he said, which became the reason management gave him notice to leave.

The Low Income Housing Institute operates Maple Court and declined to comment on his case, citing privacy issues, but said that kicking in a door would be a serious concern.

Despite staying in the shelter for months, Hamilton found he didn’t have any formal right to challenge management’s decision. The shelter had a grievance process he tried to follow, but he said he never heard back.

There wasn't enough time to get supplies to help him survive, like a tent and sleeping bag, which had been thrown away when he moved in, he said. Within about a week, he was back by the freeway in the middle of winter, with only a coat.

“I wasn't able to have a word, my side of it or anything,” Hamilton said. “That's what it was.”


New legal territory

Hamilton eventually got connected to Graf, as word spread of her working with people in shelters, and, through that police encounter, she fought for him to get back into Maple Court, where he would stay for at least another year.

But that wasn’t until after he’d spent nearly all of winter outside. She said her other clients were put out in similar circumstances, with little notice to prepare.

“That's how people die,” Graf said.

Graf believes the law afforded them more due process.

Washington state’s Residential Landlord Tenant Act outlines what types of living situations must follow eviction rules and makes no mention of homeless shelters. However, in 2021, lawmakers did add transitional housing, which are programs that are supposed to be longer-term than shelters and typically involve a lease.

To Graf, the law’s definition — nonprofit or government housing programs with services lasting up to 24 months — was indistinguishable from her clients’ experiences in tiny homes and converted hotels.

But even if that definition doesn't apply, she said there are foundational principles in Washington law that would entitle people in these shelters to at least a day in court.



Some experts agree with her. Seattle University law professor Sara Rankin said the law allows a broad definition of housing. The key question is whether the person is living in the place as their home: Are they storing their things and returning night after night, for example?

“If it walks like housing and functions like housing, the laws treat it like housing,” she said.

But this is new legal territory, and judges haven’t shared their opinion.

To the extent Thurston County government officials have gone along with her argument, it’s mainly been to avoid further lawsuits.

Olympia’s Assistant City Manager Stacey Ray said the city now requires the eviction process for city-operated tiny homes “out of an abundance of caution.”

In Lacey, a police officer said in a 2025 court affidavit that the city attorney was also requiring an eviction process for people in the hotel shelter, although a department spokesperson insisted that’s not an official policy.

Shelter providers, for their part, firmly disagree with Graf.

The Low Income Housing Institute, which has been on the receiving end of two of her lawsuits, said the people in its shelters don’t receive mail. They don’t have a lease. They don’t pay fees like utilities. And they receive food. They operate like a program providing services — not like a landlord renting to tenants.


‘A totally different operation’

If shelter providers were considered landlords, they said it would have consequences for the entire homelessness response system.

Those who operate in Thurston County said their experience shows how imposing an eviction policy has jeopardized efforts to get people off the streets.

Catholic Community Services of Western Washington manages one of Olympia’s tiny home shelters and said it only ever removes people for safety concerns. Now that the nonprofit has to follow the eviction process, it takes months to address any situation that comes up. The shelter has to cover attorney fees and manage records requests.

That puts stress on staff and distracts from efforts to get other people housed, the regional director Mike Curry said in an email.

Resources that would otherwise be devoted to serving dozens of other people become concentrated on a single case,” he said.

At the end of it all, he said, the outcome is the same: The person still has to leave.

Since Olympia began requiring evictions in its tiny homes roughly two years ago, the total number has been few. But Ray, the assistant city manager, who responded to questions in writing, said Olympia still worries its eviction policy makes shelter operators more hesitant to accept people with greater challenges.

Lee, of the Low Income Housing Institute, said that would have to be the case.

She said shelters can take anyone off the street without understanding their challenges because they know they can remove people quickly if they turn out to be violent or destructive. This includes people struggling with drug addiction and mental illness.

But she said shelters would be reluctant to do that if their only recourse were the eviction process.

“If we had to screen them to figure out whether they would make sense for the program,” Lee said, “it would be a totally different operation.”

Legal aid attorneys argue that if people commit a crime, shelters can have them arrested. But Lee said that in her nonprofit’s experience with rental properties, police are reluctant to intervene. Either that or courts release people quickly and they return to their housing.

Lee said many shelters would simply close.


A fair process

Catholic Community Services and the Low Income Housing Institute operate in King County as well, where the majority of the state’s shelter is concentrated, including more than a thousand units in tiny homes and hotel shelters. Mayor Katie Wilson is hoping to fund several hundred more.

Wilson has stressed the importance of getting people into housing from shelter. But with federal funding for permanent housing constrained under the Trump administration and roughly 18,000 estimated to be homeless in the region, the options will likely remain limited.

Her team declined to comment on whether people staying in shelters long term should have the right to the eviction process, and leaders like her haven’t been forced to confront the issue: No attorney has advocated for such protections in King County to the extent that Graf has in Thurston County.

Graf said she isn’t naive about the issues people struggle with as they transition from living outside to inside. But even if providers don’t receive rent, they often receive government funding, she said. Without a court process, there’s little accountability.

And she doesn’t know how long people will be living in these shelters.

“There is this whole class of housing and tenancy, and residency that's being created,” Graf said, adding, “there's a push to say, well, they don't get the same rights as everybody else.”

Unless lawsuits like hers reach a higher court, the issue may stay at a standstill. The city of Olympia has asked, in its legislative priorities, for state lawmakers to weigh in.

But state Rep. Nicole Macri, D-Seattle, said she isn’t sure whether it would make sense for her colleagues to review the law. While she has worked to bolster tenant protections in Washington law, she has also operated shelters at the Downtown Emergency Services Center, so she sees both sides.

Macri believes eviction protections could apply to people in shelters depending on how they operate. However, she questioned whether the court system was the best fit to handle these cases.

Most of all, she said, providers should have fair policies that weigh the seriousness of putting someone back outside.

“The main issue is you have to treat people with dignity and respect. And I'm not suggesting that the providers aren't doing that,” Macri said, “but why would people bring lawsuits?”

© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.