Through about 70 minutes of play at Tiger Stadium on Thursday, the second matchup between Centralia and W.F. West felt very similar to the first.
The Bearcats took an early lead, the Tigers tied it, and W.F. West jumped back in front early in the second half. In that first meeting on Oct. 6, Centralia was able to salvage a draw with a goal in the final moments.
“We talked about just learning some of those lessons from the first time,” W.F. West coach Kevin Schultz. “Making sure we took advantage of the opportunity when we got it.”
The Bearcats didn’t miss their chance to end it on Thursday, as a Mirabel Burger goal on a free kick in the 76th minute gave W.F. West the insurance it needed to secure The Chronicle Cup and the 2A EvCo league title with a 3-1 victory over Centralia.
“Getting that third one, it was the one thing we didn’t do last time,” Schultz said. “They’re just so resilient. We have so much faith in ourselves that we’re gonna find a way to get it done that you just expect something to happen. And it happened.”
After the game, the Bearcats celebrated with The Chronicle Cup trophy, and shortly after leaving Tiger Stadium, they learned that Black Hills and Tumwater drew in their matchup, a result that secured W.F. West’s first EvCo title since 2012.
“Clinching a league title in a win against your rival makes the win just a little sweeter,” Schultz admitted.
Burger’s free kick gave the W.F. West bench the sigh of relief it was looking for, as it put W.F. West up two with less than five minutes to play.
Burger opened the scoring back in the eighth minute on an assist from Sable Bunker, but Centralia’s Ty Leal-Minor tied the game off an assist from Maddie Ahern in the 33rd minute.
Eight minutes into the second half, Taylor Tobin won a battle for possession in the right side of the box and slotted a pass towards Izzy Teeter in the middle. Teeter lined up a shot and fired it into the top left to put W.F. West back ahead.
Like the first meeting, Centralia didn’t go quietly, instead sending numbers forward and generating a few chances to tie the game.
“I’m just proud because they didn’t give up,” Centralia coach Luis Magana said. “They kept fighting … They’re still going all out.”
The Tigers (3-10-2, 1-7-1 2A EvCo) have now gone eight straight games without a win, a stretch that includes seven losses and the tie against W.F. West. The Tigers have not won since Sept. 24, and for the first time in Magana’s tenure at Centralia, they’ve been eliminated from playoff contention.
“It does hurt, and it does sting,” Magana said. “The thing I told them was ‘hey, let’s just play hard.’ That’s what they did. I enjoy watching them play hard because it shows the potential that could have been, but it also makes me sad because it shows the potential that could have been.”
“We just couldn’t figure it out,” Magana continued. “But I just told the younger class, let’s learn from this type of experience. Let’s keep going. Let’s keep working hard.”
Magana commended two of his juniors, Ahern and Peyton Thurman, for their play on Thursday, saying that they are among the group that Magana is excited to see back in the fold in 2027.
Schultz also commended his younger players, including Burger, a freshman who hit the 20-goal mark in the win, Teeter, a junior, and both Sable Bunker and Sophia Abbarno, two sophomores.
“Between Dina (Silva) and Cyndal (Sills), (Centralia) probably has the best central midfield pairing in our league,” Schultz said. “For Sophia having to sit alone as that defensive midfielder, I thought she did really well tonight.
“Other than that, I thought Sable was really, really active,” Schultz added. “We have younger players that are stepping up in these big moments right now.”
In the coming seasons, those younger players will attempt to keep The Chronicle Cup trophy in Chehalis, something W.F. West’s 2026 senior class has been able to do in all four of its seasons.
Before then, though, the Bearcats (12-0-4, 7-0-1) will wrap up their regular season on Tuesday before turning their attention to the district tournament.
As the No. 1 seed, W.F. West will host a quarterfinal game next Saturday, Oct. 31 against the No. 4 seed from the Greater St. Helens League.
Centralia will host Black Hills for its Senior Night on Monday.