The Quinault Indian Nation has requested that a new idea for flood reduction be considered as part of the programmatic EIS being conducted on the Chehalis Basin to reduce flood and restore the fish runs.  

This programmatic EIS process was recommended by the Governor’s Chehalis Basin Work Group, approved by the governor and funded by the Legislature this year.  

The EIS, by law, must be objective and consider several options including the plan produced by the Work Group to both restore fish habitat and to address flooding through measures including a dam on the upper Chehalis River. 

The technical work on the draft programmatic EIS is to be completed by next summer, followed by a recommendation of a preferred alternative by the Work Group and a decision by the governor in December 2016.    

At a recent public meeting, the natural resources director for the Quinaults acknowledged that this idea is coming late to the process but the programmatic EIS process should consider an alternative flood reduction plan that relies on natural structures to reduce flood levels.

I understand the analysis of this alternative can fit within the timeline to reach a decision by the governor next December and I support it being evaluated in this process.  

The Work Group has directed research and analysis of many large-scale alternatives on flood reduction including, dredging, removal of bridges, changing logging practices, creating a floodway bypass at Mellen Street and many dam designs.  

The results of the evaluations of these alternatives are all public record and can be found on the Chehalis Basin Flood Authority website.   

The alternative to use more natural approaches to address flooding has been raised by others in the past and we should see whether this can provide benefit to our communities.

This alternative can be evaluated by the team of hydrologists, biologists, geologists, engineers and economists that have analyzed all of these other ideas and everyone will be able to see their conclusions.

The Chronicle editorialized that the action by the Quinaults was obstructionist. 

The Quinaults have come to the table with an idea acknowledging that flooding is a problem that must be addressed alongside habitat and fish restoration in the Chehalis basin.  

Let’s have the scientists get the facts and not question motives.


J. Vander Stoep is an attorney in Chehalis. He serves on the Chehalis River Basin Flood Authority and the Governor’s Chehalis Basin Work Group.

Recommended for you

(2) comments


"The alternative to use more natural approaches to address flooding has been raised by others in the past and we should see whether this can provide benefit to our communities."

Seems like this is a notion that should've already been vetted in the 20+ years spent "studying" flooding, Mr. Vander Stoep. Not that it matters. These studies will seemingly go on into perpetuity, costing taxpayers millions without a shovel ever being turned and flooding unabated. Nice work if you can get it.


"natural approaches to address flooding". What kinds and specific "natural approaches" are we talking about? I've driven up and down I-5 for many decades, and been driven up and down it since I was a kid in the 1950's, before there was even an I-5. I've noticed flooding in what were then farm fields every winter. If there weren't "natural approaches" that far back, I doubt the situation has ever changed during any human settlement (euro or indigenous). Therefore, no mitigation can be "natural", so go with the most effective solution, which includes flood control dams.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.